Pay B2B Marketers Like Salespeople: The Case for Marketing Performance Commission

Brace yourself, because this might initially ruffle some feathers among marketers, salespeople, and founders alike. But hear me out: paying marketers like salespeople, with performance-based commissions, isn’t as wild as it sounds. The deeper you dig, the more it starts to feel not just reasonable but potentially transformative. Let’s dive in.

A Clear Link Between Pay and Performance

Sales teams have been thriving on performance-based compensation for decades. It’s a proven formula: clear incentives drive clear results. But can marketers, whose impact often feels broader and less immediate, reap the same benefits? With the right metrics and expectations, yes, they can—and they should.

Thanks for reading The Gossamer Manifesto! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Subscribe

Why This Works

• Commercial Expectations Require Commercial Pay: Marketing is no longer just about crafting clever campaigns; it’s a revenue-driving function. Aligning compensation with this expectation feels natural.
• Aligned Performance Tracking: Paying marketers based on performance forces executive teams and marketing leaders to set—and actually track—clear, measurable goals.
• Focus on What Matters During Growth: In fast-paced growth phases, this model centers the team on driving outcomes rather than simply activity.

A Model for Marketing Performance Pay

Here’s what performance-based marketing compensation might look like:

1. Annual Performance Bonus:
   Tied to commercial metrics like pipeline generated or closed ARR attributable to marketing. Importantly, these metrics shouldn’t compete with sales targets—they should align.
2. Team Incentives Over Two Years:
   A rolling incentive program that recognizes less tangible contributions, such as brand building or operational efficiency, while still rewarding commercial performance.
3. Accelerated Milestones for Major Wins:
   Extra rewards for pivotal moments—first strategic account acquisition, successful VC funding rounds, or major product launches.

This structure keeps marketers grounded in the commercial realities of their work while rewarding both short-term and long-term successes.

The Benefits Beyond the Paycheck

Helps Marketers Prioritize

A performance-linked pay model teaches marketers to focus on pulling the right levers for growth. It bridges the gap between immediate needs and long-term strategy, creating a balanced approach.

Drives Alignment with Sales

Let’s face it: the stereotype of marketers casually logging on mid-morning while sales teams grind through the quarter-end is alive and well. This model helps squash that resentment, fostering shared goals and mutual respect.

Moves Metrics from Vanity to Value

No more patting ourselves on the back for impressions and clicks. Compensation tied to real business outcomes nudges marketers to focus on value-driving metrics like revenue, pipeline, or customer retention.

Motivates Teams to Manage Agencies Effectively

When in-house marketers have skin in the game, they’ll naturally demand more accountability and ROI from external partners.

What About Non-Performance Roles?

Not all marketing roles directly drive pipeline. Product marketers and operations specialists, for instance, are enablers, not hunters. Should they be left out of the performance-pay party? No. Here’s how they can still benefit:

• Team Bonuses: Shared incentives tied to overall marketing performance ensure everyone pulls in the same direction.
• Recognizing Multiplicative Impact: Growth marketers thrive when brand and operational functions excel. Compensating the whole team ensures that these enablers aren’t undervalued.
• Meaningful Rewards: Bonuses should be significant enough to matter—something that motivates beyond a token gesture.

Conclusion

Does this approach fly in the face of the “trust the process” mantra? Not really. Performance doesn’t mean chasing short-term wins at the expense of long-term growth. It means setting appropriate timeframes and expectations—and then delivering.

Yes, there’s a risk that underperformance could lead to firings, but isn’t that a reality in any results-driven role? The upside is worth the discomfort: a marketing team motivated not just to work hard, but to deliver measurable impact—and earn more when they do.